What to Do When Someone Plagiarizes Your Family History Work
Someone copied your family history work? Save a dated record, ask once in writing, and weigh formal options. What the law covers, from someone it happened to.
Someone copied your family history work, and you want to know what to do next. For family historians, the answer starts with a dated record of what you made, then one private ask, then a choice about whether anything more is worth your time.
I've had my work taken many times over the years, most recently a whole course, and I handled each case differently — some of those ways worked better than others.
Here's what I'd do now, what the law covers and doesn't, and why the strongest defense you have is publishing more of your own work.
What counts as plagiarism of family history work
Plagiarism is presenting someone else's work as your own. Copyright is the legal piece of it, and it covers less than most family historians expect.
Facts are not protected. The Supreme Court settled that in Feist v. Rural in 1991, holding that facts aren't original, so they can't be copyrighted. A birth date, a census entry, a transcribed headstone: anyone can use them.
What is protected is your expression. That means the sentences you wrote, the chronicle you shaped, and the way you selected and arranged what you found. Methods are not protected either. Federal law says copyright never extends to an "idea, procedure, process, system, method of operation."
So someone can teach your approach in their own words without breaking copyright law. They're still claiming credit for work you did, and that's the part that stings.
Before we move on, I'm not a lawyer. This is the general shape of the law, not advice on your situation. I'm sharing what I've learned and what happened to me. Consult with your own attorney if you find your work plagiarized.
Save the record before you say anything
The first move you should make is quiet. Before you email anyone, capture what you found and what you made.
- Their version: screenshots with the date and full web address showing, plus a saved copy of the page, because pages change fast once someone knows they've been noticed.
- Your version: the published date, your drafts, your file dates, and any email where you sent the work to someone.
- The overlap: your words next to theirs, side by side, in one document for you alone.
That side-by-side is for your files. Its value is that it exists, it's dated, and I can point to it once, privately, if I ever need to.
A Making Log helps here more than people expect. It's a dated record of how you made a chronicle, including the records you used and the choices you made along the way. That record is proof of authorship, and it can't be copied along with the text.
What's been taken: whole paragraphs, prompts and talks
To get an idea of what could be plagarized, here is some of what has happened to me over the past few years. Each of these was a human taking my work (not AI) with entire paragraphs and pages, copied and published.
- Entire paragraphs in society newsletters and posts. Genealogy societies have lifted whole paragraphs from my blog and newsletter for their presentations, newsletters and social posts. I used to pay attention to this and stopped.
- A talk I was under contract not to share, turned into a Custom GPT. Someone built a Custom GPT from a conference presentation of mine and published it on her own Substack. She put my name on it and encouraged others to use it, but she never asked me for permission to use my material. I sent one message asking her to take it down, and she did.
- A talk taught back under someone else's name. A session I presented turned up later as another speaker's workshop, same title and same points. I said nothing publicly and kept my receipts.
- A whole course, turned into a workshop proposal. A credentialed genealogist paid to join my community, went through a course, then drafted a three-hour workshop from it, crediting her name as the developer. She told me she used an AI tool to take my name and attribution off the material. I took her proposal and lined it up to my materials and the wording in my course and it matched 90%. I removed her and published much of the material on my website.
When it's your name and face instead of your words
Two situations I've run into were not copying my writing, but using my name and face to promote someone else's work. One person used my name to bring readers into her own newsletter. I asked her in writing to stop, and she didn't, so I asked a second time and that one worked.
Another put my name, my photo and my comments on the page for her new paid workshop. Those comments were about a different workshop I'd taken over a year earlier, and I don't recall ever writing a testimonial. I asked her to remove all of it, and she did within sixteen minutes.
In both cases my name and face were just slapped on their work like I don't exist as human being to be considered. That isn't plagiarism, legally speaking, but it's definitely unethical.
Here's what every case on this page has in common, from the society newsletters to the course. Not one person asked me first. Not an email, not a message. Just copy, paste, publish. And then when I ask to take it down, I'm made to feel like the jerk for asking.
Why I don't call people out in public
Now after reading all this you might be thinking, why don't you call this out when it happens? It feels like the right move to post about it, name the person and let the community decide. I've watched what happens next, and it's rarely what the person who was copied wanted.
Two years ago I watched an original creator of family history work call out a copier on three platforms. The copier answered with a long video about bullying in the family history world. Her viewers never saw the original work and only saw the story about being attacked, and the original creator who was copied became the villain of it.
When the public becomes the arbiter of what happened, the situation can go in a direction that ends up taking more of your time and energy to come to resolve.
What to do in public instead: thank them and add the link
When a copy shows up somewhere public, there's a middle path between silence and a call-out. One of those societies was posting parts of my blog posts on Facebook with no link back to the originals. So I replied in the comments: "Thank you so much for mentioning my latest post! Here is the full link for everyone."
I treated what was copied as a mention and finished it for them. Every reader of that post now had my name and the link to the original. The comment was warm, so nobody had anything to push back on, and anyone could see where the words came from.
After I'd done it twice, the copying stopped on social media — nobody had to be told they did something wrong. They got tired of looking like they were promoting me. It cost me two comments and about a minute each.
When to ask privately, and how many times
One private ask, in writing, short, and mine is often a question. In 2021 I found an item in that same society's newsletter that matched my own email newsletter word for word. My whole email was two lines: "It looks like #10 below is copied and pasted from my email newsletter. Can you confirm?"
The editor wrote back the next morning, said she'd meant to note the source, and apologized. Three days later she offered to feature my website in the next issue. A short question is easy to answer honestly, and it leaves a dated record that they were told.
If you'd rather state it outright, name the work, where it appeared, and what you want: take it down, or add your name and a link. If nothing changes, ask once more. If two asks don't get results, a third won't either.
Expect one reply in particular. When I asked for the Custom GPT to come down, the answer was "I thought I was helping you." It's usually sincere, and it doesn't change anything. My reply was one sentence: "Taking my work and publishing it under your name and encouraging others to use it doesn't help me."
Formal options when a private ask doesn't work
If the copy sits on a website, the host usually has a copyright complaint process. In the United States that's a DMCA takedown notice, sent to the platform rather than the person. Blogging platforms, YouTube and most web hosts have a form for it.
For money damages, there's a smaller option than federal court. The Copyright Claims Board is a tribunal inside the U.S. Copyright Office that hears disputes up to $30,000.
The other side can opt out, and your copyright has to be registered before the board makes a final decision. Federal court generally requires registration before you file. But as we covered at the top of this post, most family history work is difficult to cover under copyright.
Most of us will never go that far, and again, I'm not a lawyer, so if real money is at stake, talk to one.
The defense that works: be first, named and public
Since methods can't be copyrighted, the protection that holds is being first, in public, with your name on it. A dated page with your name and your framework on it is evidence nobody can strip. Anyone who teaches it later is teaching something that already exists somewhere searchable.
That's why I publish my frameworks as permanent pages on this site, each dated and under my name. The STORI Method went up in May 2026 and the Research Quality Check in July. If someone presents either as their own, the original is one search away.
The same thinking works for your own writing. Publish your chronicle somewhere you control, with a date.
Put your name in the text itself, not only the byline. Name your sources so the research trail is visibly yours. A copy that drops your name still carries your fingerprints.
What AI tools changed about attribution
Taking someone's name off a document used to take an evening of retyping. Now it takes one request to an AI tool, and a whole presentation can become a Custom GPT in an afternoon. The workshop proposal I described above came with a note that an AI tool took my name off, and the choice to do that was still hers, not the tool's.
That cuts both ways, because keeping a record got easier right along with removing a name. A Making Log, dated drafts and a published page each take minutes now. Whoever holds the earlier dated record holds the stronger position.
It's also why I'm careful with the word authorship when I talk about writing with AI. Authorship is the choices you made, and a dated record of those choices is your proof. Whether you used a tool is a separate question, one I take up in is it cheating to use AI for family history. My standard for recording what a person does with AI is the Making Process.
For the other side of it, giving credit where you owe it, see How to Credit Other People's Work in Your Family History.
You can keep making things
Having your work taken feels like a reason to stop sharing. I've felt that pull every time, and I keep going anyway, because the taking tells me something useful: somebody thought the work was worth building on.
Save the record. Ask once, then once more. Choose whether anything formal is worth your hours. Then go back to the work — more of it, published and dated under your name, is the defense that keeps working.